Play-to-earn falling out of favor after 'massive shift in priority' — BGA survey

The blockchain gaming industry is experiencing a "massive shift," with the once-popular play-to-earn (P2E) model falling out of favor and focus directed now at  improving gameplay experience, a new survey has found. 

The survey results were included in a newly released annual report from the Blockchain Game Alliance (BGA) on Jan. 12, which was conducted with 347 professionals, representing 252 different projects or companies in the blockchain sector.

Most of the respondents were young adult males working for blockchain gaming companies in middle and top management positions, according to BGA. 

One of the trends gleaned from the report was an apparent shift in how blockchain gaming executives viewed P2E as a driver for blockchain gaming adoption.

In 2021, the report found 67.9% of respondents agreeing that P2Es would be the most significant growth driver of blockchain gaming. The latest survey found this number shrinking to just 22.5%.

Instead, gameplay improvements was seen as the biggest driver for adoption in 2023 with 35.7 of respondents saying gameplay improvements will be the industry's top priority.

Pedro Heddera, head of research and analytics at Dapp insights company Dappradar cited P2E’s fading out as a result of “falling crypto prices and upcoming free-to-earn games” paving the way for the new generation of web3 games, adding:

“2023 is shaping up to be a make-or-break year.”

Co-founder of web3 consulting company Blockminds Rowan Zwiers stated in the report that despite the previous hype achieved by P2E games during the first generation of blockchain gaming, the industry is currently in the midst of a “drawback to normalcy.”

Zwiers said that P2E models have “proven themselves unsustainable” but showed the need for the development of the next generation of more advanced blockchain gaming dynamics.

Meanwhile, Chief Investment Officer of Hartmann Metaverse Ventures Felix Hartmann said that “cheap point-and-click browser” P2E’s are no longer getting the funding they used to get as “capital has gotten smarter and more demanding.”

Hartmann suggested that venture capitalists are turning their attention to a better experience for gamers. He noted:

“More cutting-edge game studios integrating web3 and AI into Unreal Engine-based, high-fidelity games are seeing more traction.”

Despite the decline in popularity for P2E’s, co-founder of Mirai Labs Corey Wilton said that the “lovers” of the original P2E model will always exist, but it is clearly more profitable to create games that “captures the casual everyday gamer.”

The report highlighted that poor gameplay and the problem of blockchain gaming concepts not being understood were the biggest issues in blockchain gaming.

Related: 2023 will see the death of play-to-earn gaming

Overall, the blockchain gaming industry is still growing significantly, despite the extended crypto winter, according to a section of the report supported by DappRadar.

On-chain game transactions reached 7.4 billion, growing 37% from 2021 and a staggering 3,260% since 2020.

The report stated that the crypto winter has not impacted the number of blockchain gamers for existing games.

President of the Blockchain Games Alliance Sebastien Borget said this indicates to him that the industry is “putting players first,” more so focusing on the benefits of blockchain to the gaming industry over the volatile market.