Overstock Wants Lawsuit Nixed Ahead of Security Token Distribution

Published at: May 14, 2020

Online retailer and early Bitcoin adopter Overstock has filed for the dismissal of a lawsuit that accuses the company of misrepresenting the nature of its ‘digital dividend’ token.

The dividend is a security token airdrop that will see ‘OSTKO’ tokens distributed to company shareholders on a basis of one token to every ten Overstock shares.

News of the dividend caused a share price surge and the lead plaintiff accuses Overstock of deliberately withholding information regarding the distribution, and of deceiving the market to intentionally punish short sellers.

Overstock’s digital dividend distribution is set to take place on May 19.

Overstock rejects manipulation accusations

For its part, Overstock argues the lead plaintiff in the case, The Mangrove Partners Master Fund is a “well-known short-seller,” despite claiming to be an institutional investor.

In its filing, Overstock asserts "There is no allegation that Overstock misrepresented the nature of the Dividend, or sought to hide the impact it would have on short sellers.” 

“In fact, Plaintiff concedes that the impact was widely known and reported from day one. This alone warrants dismissal," the firm adds.

Overstock accused of market manipulation

The consolidated suit also accuses Overstock, ex-CEO and founder Patrick Byrne, former CFO Gregory Iverson, and current retail president David Nielson of violating securities laws amid Byrne’s sudden departure from the company and the liquidation of 20% of his Overstock shares last year.

The suit claims that Overstock issued misleading year-end predictions concerning the profitability of its security token exchange tZERO to drive up the price of OSTK shares — allowing Byrne to cash out at a premium.

On top of the bullish fervor surrounding tZERO, news of the digital dividend drove the price of OSTK up over 97% during September — resulting in over $90 million in profits to Byrne, the suit alleges.

Overstock later conceded that its previous year-end guidance was inaccurate, culminating in a series of OSTK price crashes.

Tags
Regulation
Tokens
Law
Overstock
Related Posts
Dubai financial regulator working on regulations for cryptocurrencies
The Dubai Financial Services Authority, the financial regulatory agency for the special economic zone, the Dubai International Financial Centre, is looking to enhance local cryptocurrency-related regulations. The DFSA is planning to introduce a regulatory framework for diverse digital assets as part of its 2021–2022 business plan released on Jan. 18. According to the DFSA, the upcoming crypto framework will further expand the DFSA’s regulation of digital asset issuers and associated trading platforms. The framework will include a number of digital asset types like tokenized securities and cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin (BTC): “We will build upon recent achievements in this space over …
Bitcoin / Jan. 19, 2021
SEC Orders ICO Startup to Return $25.5M to Investors
The United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has ordered cryptocurrency firm BitClave to return $25.5 million to investors. In a May 28 announcement, the SEC announced charges against the California-based cryptocurrency startup. The regulator found BitClave to be responsible for selling unregistered securities in its initial coin offering. Chief of the SEC Enforcement Division’s Cyber Unit Kristina Littman commented: “Issuers of securities, traditional or digital, must comply with the registration requirements of the federal securities laws. [...] The remedies ordered by the Commission will provide meaningful relief to investors in this unregistered offering.” The SEC said, “BitClave agreed to …
Regulation / May 29, 2020
US judge dismisses crypto fraud case against BNT token issuer
A federal district court in the United States has dismissed a securities fraud class action against Israel-based cryptocurrency firm Bancor. U.S. district judge Alvin Hellerstein ruled on Monday to dismiss a case against Bancor, stating that plaintiffs had failed to allege losses as well as citing lack of personal jurisdiction. The judge has also canceled an oral argument scheduled for March 4, 2021, entering judgment in favor of the defendants. The case was brought by New York law firms Roche Cyrulnik Freedman and Selendy & Gay in April 2020, alleging that the Bancor protocol developer, BProtocol Foundation, violated federal and …
Regulation / Feb. 24, 2021
Ideas vs. practice: How are regulators working together on crypto?
The regulation of cryptocurrencies across the world is a constant battle for investors in a rapidly expanding and constantly changing ecosystem. Various regulatory agencies around the world view digital assets in a different light that vary significantly from one another. Recently, executive board member of the European Central Bank (ECB) Fabio Panetta mentioned in a written statement for a speech to Columbia University that regulators should follow a globally coordinated approach while regulating digital assets. He said that the world should have digital assets regulated by the Anti-Money Laundering (AML) and Countering the Financing of Terrorism (CFT) rules of the …
Decentralization / May 25, 2022
CBDC activity heats up, but few projects move beyond pilot stage
Government-issued electronic currency seems to be an idea whose time has come. “More than half of the world’s central banks are now developing digital currencies or running concrete experiments on them,” reported the Bank for International Settlements, or BIS, in early May — something that would have been unthinkable only a few years ago. The BIS also found that nine out of ten central banks were exploring central bank digital currencies, or CBDCs, in some form or other, according to its survey of 81 central banks conducted last autumn but just published. Many were taken aback by the progress. “It …
Adoption / May 16, 2022