Is Bitcoin Price Really Influenced by the Grayscale GBTC Premium?

Published at: July 22, 2020

Recently the Grayscale Bitcoin Trust Fund (GBTC) premium to net asset value (NAV) reached its lowest level since November 2018. This premium shows that traders are paying more for GBTC shares than the underlying Bitcoin (BTC) quantity held by the fund.

This difference is caused mostly due to retail investors inability to purchase shares directly from Grayscale Investments, whose funds are aimed exclusively for accredited investors.

Currently, GBTC is the largest cryptocurrency listed investment fund with $3.5 billion assets under management, totaling over 386,000 BTC under custody. Therefore, it is considered a relevant indicator of investors appetite.

The recent decreases in this premium raised some eyebrows amongst analysts and crypto pundits who claimed it might signal the beginning of a significant move, as per previous similar moments.

What’s behind the GBTC premium?

Grayscale Bitcoin Trust (GBTC) premium to net assets. Source: YCharts

Over the past two years, there have been four instances where the GBTC premium marked a local bottom and bounced back up. As shown above, upticks in the premium marked short-term bull moments in three out of four occurrences.

The only exception was the notorious November 2018 crash that occurred after Bitcoin lost its longtime $6,000 support. Given the decreasing premium, investors will now question if the ‘signal’ could be predicting a similar movement. July 16 marked the lowest levels in twenty months, and now the premium seems to be bouncing back to 9%.

To correctly assess whether the current moment resembles the past negative outcome, one needs to analyze investor sentiment back then. One of the best metrics trading wise is the futures premium (contango) and market volume.

Futures markets show some similarities

Contango measures longer-term futures contracts premium and provides a reliable indicator to investors’ expectations. 

There’s usually a 0.5% to 1.5% premium on 3-month contracts in healthy markets, indicating a normal contango. When this indicator goes negative, known as backwardation, it is a signal of bearishness.

OKEx 3-month BTC futures premium. Source: TradingView

The 3-month futures contract premium stands at a modest 1% to the current Bitcoin price, similar to the level found in November 2018. Although not a bearish level, such contango does not show any excessive optimism from professional traders.

Volume fluctuations paint a similar picture

Volume is unarguably the most relevant metric investors track. Although there can be an infinite number of reasons for increased investor interest, there’s nothing positive to be gleaned from dwindling trading activity. 

To better assess such metrics, one should also look at futures contracts. While conflicting trends are not common, they could explain any volume changes in the underlying asset.

20-day average BTC volumes in 2018. Source: TradingView

Volume in derivatives, fiat, and USDT-based exchanges were in a steep reduction in the November 2018 crash. As shown in the chart below, the same set of worrisome indicators exist.

20-day average BTC volumes. Source: TradingView

The GBTC premium ‘signal’ is not bulletproof

In addition to the GBTC premium, contango, and volume, traders should also investigate the traders’ sentiment during the most recent occasions when the premium bottomed. 

OKEx 3-month BTC futures premium. Source: TradingView

The 3-month upfront contract premium shows three drastically different scenarios, marked by excessive optimism in January 2020 at 2%, and bearish sentiment in April 2020 at -1%.

BTC futures trading below the spot price is a typical signal of discomfort from professional investors and this scenario is referred to as backwardation.

October 2019 was the only instance resembling November 2018 and the current level at a rather neutral 1% premium. To gain further insight into this, one should check volume trends to understand if previous GBTC low premium instances correlate to the present moment.

20-day average BTC volumes. Source: TradingView

The only instance showing a downtrend in volume seems to be April 20. However, the volume spike was caused by the market activity on March 13 when Bitcoin faced a 20% crash in a single hour. The figures from April 20 can’t be deemed low compared to the previous couple of months.

Current indicators mirror the November 2018 crash

Three indicators are currently mirroring the pre-November 2018 crash: decreasing volume, a rather neutral 1% 3-months futures premium, and the GBTC premium bouncing from lows. 

The thing to remember is history doesn’t repeat itself, but it tends to rhyme. There is no such thing as an unfailing indicator, even if many point in the same direction. Investors get nervous each time Bitcoin tests its $9,000 support, and they have many reasons for that. 

It’s possible that relying on the GBTC premium as a signal will be another self-fulfilling prophecy as so many analysts are calling for a sharp negative move from Bitcoin, but only time will tell.

The views and opinions expressed here are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of Cointelegraph. Every investment and trading move involves risk. You should conduct your own research when making a decision.

Tags
Bitcoin
Bitcoin Price
Markets
Market Analysis
Gbtc
Related Posts
Bitcoin price set to rebound? BTC shorts on Bitfinex crash by 25% after record spikes
Bitcoin (BTC) bears should watch out for a potential blow as the number of margined short positions on the Bitfinex exchange crashes by roughly 25%. The dataset dropped to 11,066 BTC as of 12:20 GMT Saturday, compared to 14,897 BTC at the session's open. Meanwhile, the drop came as a part of a bigger downside move that started on July 15. On the day, the total number of margined short positions had reached 17,053 BTC. In simple terms, BTCUSDSHORTS represents the number of margined bearish positions on Bitfinex, measured in BTC. Traders borrow funds from Bitfinex — their broker — …
Bitcoin / July 17, 2021
Record outflows from Canada’s biggest Bitcoin fund see BTC reserves drop by 50%
A Canada-based Bitcoin fund, operated by 3iQ Corp, has witnessed a dramatic decline in its BTC reserves since June. Literally named the Bitcoin Fund (QBTC:CN), the closed-end investment product, was holding around 24,000 BTC in its vaults in early June. However, as the monthly session progressed, the reserves first dropped to below 16,000 BTC in a dramatic, straight-line decline. Later, another massive withdrawal pushed the Bitcoin Fund's BTC reserves to around 13,000 BTC, according to on-chain data from South Korea-based analytics firm CryptoQuant. However, the withdrawals from the QBTC fund across June coincided with an inflow spike in 3iQ's exchange-traded …
Bitcoin / July 15, 2021
GBTC discount presents a unique challenge for Grayscale and investors
Since 2013 the Grayscale Bitcoin Trust Fund (GBTC) has offered its investors exposure to Bitcoin (BTC) through a publicly quoted private instrument. However, the trust's convertibility and liquidity vastly differ from an Exchange Traded Fund (ETF). Trusts are structured as companies, at least in regulatory form, and are 'closed-end funds' which can initially only be sold to accredited investors. This means the number of available shares is limited, and retail traders can only access them via secondary markets. Furthermore, a GBTC share cannot be redeemed for the underlying BTC position. Historically, GBTC used to trade above the equivalent BTC held …
Etf / May 8, 2021
Institutions increase exposure to Grayscale Bitcoin Trust as GBTC discount nears 30%
Institutional investors are returning to accumulate Grayscale Bitcoin Trust (GBTC) shares as the discount to spot price his risen to nearly 30%, data on Glassnode shows. Since December 2021, some weekly sessions saw investors pouring in between $10 million and $120 million into Grayscale's flagship fund. Meanwhile, the biggest capital inflow — amounting to nearly $140 million — appeared in the week ending on Feb. 25, as shown in the chart below. No selloff yet among high-profile GBTC backers The GBTC trust attracted investments as global markets faced back-to-back shocks in the past few months, including a dramatic selloff in …
Etf / March 6, 2022
Grayscale BTC Trust trades at a record 36.7% discount, but is it justified?
U.S. investors have been waiting for a Bitcoin exchange-traded fund (ETF) approval since May 2014 when the Winklevoss Bitcoin Trust filed an amendment request at the Securities and Exchange (SEC). Over the years, the SEC has rejected every applicant and the latest denial was issued to WisdomTree’s application for a spot Bitcoin ETF on Oct. 11. The SEC concluded that the offer did not have the ability “to obtain information necessary to detect, investigate, and deter fraud and market manipulation, as well as violations of exchange rules and applicable federal securities laws and rules.” Bitcoin investment trust vehicles have existed …
Etf / Oct. 15, 2022