Indian crypto tax policy to treat each digital asset investment independently

Published at: March 21, 2022

Indian crypto tax policy became even more complicated just a week before the new tax laws are set to come into effect. A new parliamentary note answering queries about the new tax policies on virtual digital asset (VDA) suggest that traders can’t offset their losses from one digital asset against profit on another.

As the new tax policy waits for April 1 to come into effect, many experts claim the latest clarification from the government is a death knell for traders. The crypto tax policy of the government expects traders to treat each investment and profit/loss on a digital asset independently.

For example, if a trader invests $100 each in Bitcoin (BTC) and Ether (ETH), and they incur a profit of $100 on Ether and a loss of $100 on Bitcoin, then the trader would have to pay a 30% tax on the profit of Ethereum without accounting for losses on BTC.

WazirX founder Nischal Shetty called the tax policy regressive and “unbelievable,” while hoping the government changes its stance. He told Cointelegraph:

“Treating profits and losses of each market pair separately will discourage crypto participation and throttle the industry's growth. It’s very unfortunate, and we urge the government to reconsider this.”

Apart from the latest burden of treating each crypto trading pair independently, the 1% tax deduction at source (TDS) on each transaction is also being criticized by crypto entrepreneurs and especially exchanges, as they believe it would dry up liquidity.

Crypto entrepreneur Naimish Sanghvi suggested that traders should sell everything they have before March 31, 2022, and start fresh from April 2022.

My suggestion to sell off everything applies to those who are in overall profit. That way you can still offset your losses with profits before March 31. If you’re only in profit, or only in loss across all your investments, then it’s wise to just hold! https://t.co/4RxKH8xKOT

— Naimish Sanghvi (@ThatNaimish) March 21, 2022

India is yet to finalize a regulatory framework for the crypto Industry despite several assurances by the government since 2018. While many hoped the introduction of taxes would offer some form of legitimacy to the crypto industry, the finance ministry made it clear that the industry would gain any legal status only after the passing of the crypto bill.

Related: India’s crypto tax provides little legal clarity for traders and exchanges

The crypto tax policy itself seems to be inspired by the country’s gambling/lottery tax laws which kind of reflects the government’s approach towards the crypto market.

Seems like, Idea for crypto tax policy came from here. pic.twitter.com/wuUaWQxU2f

— Aditya Singh (@CryptooAdy) March 16, 2022

Countries such as Thailand and South Korea have also proposed a similar high crypto tax, but those policies failed as the government understood it would hinder the growth of the nascent market. Korea had to postpone its 20% crypto tax while Thailand exempted traders from paying 7% value-added tax on authorized exchanges.

Tags
Regulation
Cryptocurrencies
India
Taxes
Related Posts
Law Decoded: India ponders going full China on crypto, Nov. 22–29
Are big emerging economies more likely to gravitate toward blanket crypto bans? China has set a precedent, and now it appears as if India could be weighing a similar policy direction: A bill containing a proposed ban on all “private cryptocurrencies” will go in front of the nation’s parliament sometime this winter. The measure is designed to clear the way for India’s central bank to advance its digital currency agenda. Whether a sovereign central bank digital currency can coexist with a thriving market of “private” cryptos will be one of the central questions of the looming CBDC age, and it …
Regulation / Nov. 29, 2021
Indian taxman recovers $6.62M from WazirX for evading tax on commission
Indian crypto exchange WazirX has reportedly paid over $6.62 million (49.2 crore rupees) following non-payment of Goods and Services Tax (GST) on trade commissions. The total recovery includes the pending tax of $5.43 million (40.5 crore rupees), the interest and a penalty for non-payment. Government officials from the Central GST and Central Excise committee (CGST Mumbai Zone) recovered the funds from the crypto exchange after detecting a GST evasion of $5.43 million on the commissions. A typical GST fraud involves creating fake invoices without actually moving the goods between the seller and the buyer. Officers of CGST Mumbai East comm'te …
Blockchain / Jan. 1, 2022
Proposal for crypto tax policy in India will go to parliament on March 24
A tax proposal on crypto from India’s Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman may be closer to becoming law as the country’s lower house of parliament is scheduled to consider the legislation on Thursday. According to a Wednesday publication, Sitharaman will be introducing appropriation and finance bills for 2022 to the Lok Sabha — the lower house of parliament — on March 24. The Finance Bill includes an amendment to the country’s income tax laws identifying “virtual digital assets” — including cryptocurrencies and nonfungible tokens — as taxable investments. First announced by the finance minister in February, the amendment to India’s existing …
Regulation / March 23, 2022
Crypto tax policy framework passes India's parliament despite pushback from lawmakers
A tax framework on cryptocurrencies introduced by India’s Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman will become law in the country after being passed as an amendment to the Finance Bill. India’s lower house of parliament, the Lok Sabha, passed the 2022 Finance Bill on Friday, which included 39 amendments proposed by Sitharaman. The amendment on crypto established a 30% tax targeting digital asset and nonfungible token transactions, which did not allow for deductions from trading losses while calculating income. In addition, taxpayers in India will have an additional 1% tax deducted at source, or TDS. As per the new amendment proposed in …
Regulation / March 25, 2022
30% crypto tax becomes law in India following Finance Bill approval
The Indian Finance Bill 2022 with new 30% crypto tax rules was approved by the Rajya Sabha, the upper house of the Indian parliament, to make it a law today that will come into effect starting on April 1. The approval of the bill by the upper house of the parliament comes within a week of the lower house (Lok Sabha) approval. The Finance Bill was introduced during the budget session 2022-23 of the parliament in January. The Finance Bill amended tax rules to impose a 30% crypto tax on digital asset holdings and transfers. Apart from that, traders cannot …
Regulation / March 31, 2022