Law enforcement should give up trying to access everyone's data, says legal expert

Published at: Aug. 18, 2022

While some think the Tornado Cash ban may negatively impact other projects focusing on privacy, others believe that these projects will keep pushing forward and keeping their commitments to anti-censorship and decentralization. 

In an interview with Cointelegraph, Ahmed Ghappour, the general counsel at the privacy-focused project Nym Technologies, shared insights on the importance of privacy in the crypto space, how to balance the interests of regulators and people who want privacy and what's next for privacy in Web3.

According to Ghappour, there are contradictory concepts in the Web3 space. This is the promise of returning data ownership to the people while having complete transparency regarding blockchain transactions. The lawyer noted that to fulfill these contradictory goals, privacy is the key.

However, with the Tornado Cash incident, it's apparent that privacy technologies are in the sights of United States regulators. The lawyer highlighted that this hinders the ability of the space to innovate. He said that:

“The United States is trying to swat a fly with a sledgehammer. [...] OFAC designation is meant to trigger economic sanctions primarily against countries and groups of individuals, such as terrorists and narcotics traffickers—not ideas, algorithms, or code.”

Ghappour explained that there is a good reason not to sanction ideas. It’s because the effect will be neutralizing a target by criminalizing almost any association with it, even harmless associations with clearly no ties to any other criminal conduct.

Related: Anonymous user sends ETH from Tornado Cash to prominent figures following sanctions

When asked if there's a way to balance the interests of regulators and the people who want privacy, the lawyer highlighted that it depends on the interests of regulators. Ghappour said that achieving a balance requires regulators to align their interests with the people and account for the need for privacy. He explained that:

“Achieving a balance requires law enforcement to give up on unrealistic assumptions about unfettered access to everyone’s data on a silver platter.”

Despite this, Ghappour also worries that regulators' interests are not aligned with the people at all but with the preservation of the financial surveillance status quo. Even so, the executive believes there will still be a push for projects prioritizing privacy and security at the core of technologies.

Tags
Blockchain
Regulation
Law
Web3
Privacy
Anonymity
Related Posts
The crypto industry royally screwed up privacy
Privacy is a complicated topic. Few would argue that privacy is not important. It’s generally more interesting to talk about things that are disputable. So, the limited arguments against privacy actually make it somewhat boring to discuss and easy to take for granted. As Edward Snowden famously said: “Arguing that you don't care about privacy because you have nothing to hide is like arguing that you don't care about free speech because you have nothing to say.” However, what if your privacy is not a priority? What if your privacy is not guaranteed? What if everything you do is under …
Adoption / Oct. 17, 2021
After a Decade of Promises, Blockchain Still Fails to Deliver Privacy
The first blockchain was launched more than 10 years ago and since then, it has evolved from simply being a backbone for Bitcoin (BTC) to a global technological phenomenon. In some sense, the distributed ledger became more popular than Bitcoin itself. Even the harshest cryptocurrency critics — like the government of China and JPMorgan Chase’s Jamie Dimon — recognize blockchain technology’s potential, while corporations as large as Microsoft and Accenture have adopted it to their needs. However, there is another view of blockchain technology. One that is based on the assumption that the technology has stalled in certain areas it …
Blockchain / April 24, 2020
Proposed digital euro designs lack privacy options, ECB presentation shows
Next to the fears of government overreach that the European Union’s ambitious digital euro project stirred, the main concern of the public is the prospective currency’s privacy framework. It appears that this worry might not be overblown after all, as the European Central Bank’s (ECB) latest presentation hints that user anonymity is not a desirable design option. On Tuesday, crypto venture adviser and European digital asset regulation whistleblower Patrick Hansen drew public attention to the ECB’s presentation titled “Digital Euro Privacy options.” The document is relatively short and contains nine slides that lay out the possible options for user privacy …
Regulation / May 4, 2022
Identity and the Metaverse: Decentralized control
“The Metaverse” and “Web3” are the buzzwords of the moment, with their concepts permeating across the worlds of fintech, blockchain, and now even mainstream media. With decentralization thought to be at the core of the Web3 Metaverse, the promise of a better user experience, security and control for consumers is what’s driving its growth. But with users’ identities at the heart of the Metaverse, coupled with unprecedented amounts of data online, there are concerns over data security, privacy and interoperability. This has the potential to hinder the development of the Metaverse, but both regulated and self-sovereign identities could play an …
Decentralization / May 28, 2022
Crypto lawyers to be in demand as regulatory pressure reaches boiling point
Crypto-versed lawyers will play an increasingly important role in Web3 firms — particularly after the implosion of FTX and the industry braces for regulatory turbulence, two legal academics believe. Boston Law School professor and chief compliance officer at crypto exchange Bitstamp, Thomas Hook, told Cointelegraph that Web3 lawyers will soon become “business differentiators” because they’ll be faced with the tough task of helping firms navigate through legal and regulatory uncertainties. This will ultimately determine how fast firms can take their products and services to market, Hook explained: “Given the lack of clarity in many regulations and the complexity, Web3 companies …
Adoption / Jan. 26, 2023