Hermes v MetaBirkin: NFT trademark stoush heads to trial in Manhattan

Published at: Jan. 30, 2023

The trademark infringement trial between French luxury brand Hermès and digital artist Mason Rothschild is set to go ahead on Jan. 30 in a Manhattan federal court.

The luxury brand accused the nonfungible token (NFT) artist of trademark infringement for promoting and selling MetaBirkins, an NFT collection said to be inspired by the group's Birkin bags.

The trial and its related lawsuit in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York can be first traced back to Jan. 14, 2022, when Hermès first filed a complaint against Mason Rothschild after the artist allegedly refused to stop selling his NFT collection.

According to court documents filed on Jan. 23, Hermès argues the collection has improperly used the Birkin trademark and potentially confused customers into believing the luxury brand supports the project.

Meanwhile, the court docs also reveal Rothschild believes his work is protected under the First Amendment — which allows for no limits on free expression.

Getting big life experience points this week. Putting my big boy pants on — fighting for myself and everyone who believes in the freedom to create art.

— Mason Rothschild (@MasonRothschild) January 26, 2023

A number of intellectual property lawyers and legal experts have commented in the days coming up to the trial, noting the case could have implications for the NFT industry.

Laura Lamansky, an associate with law firm Michael Best & Friedrich LLP, called the case a "momentous turning point for Web3 and digital goods," in a Jan. 18 post discussing the trial and its possible implications for the future of the NFT industry.

"The question remains: to what extent are real-world trademarks enforceable in the digital world? We'll be watching this case closely to determine how best to bolster rights in the digital sphere," she said.

"It will hopefully shed some light on how artwork and the First Amendment interact with consumer goods and NFTs and how far a brand's rights in its trademarks or products extend in the digital space," Lamansky added.

Related: ‘Wave of litigation’ to hit NFT space as copyright issues abound

Blockchain and tech lawyer Michael Kasdan has also been following the case, but he does not appear to think the result will be overly significant.

This case focuses on the line between expressive artistic reuse and infringing commercial use. Both sides have excellent counsel. In the end it’s just going to be one district court case data point but definitely an interesting one. #metabirkins #hermes #NFT #TM

— Michael Kasdan (@michaelkasdan) January 28, 2023

"In the end it's just going to be one district court case data point but definitely an interesting one," he said.

Brands and companies have begun to crack down against NFT projects which claim to violate copyright, intellectual property and trademarks.

On Feb. 4, 2022, Nike filed a lawsuit against StockX for trademark infringement as the online reseller allegedly created NFTs in the likeness of Nike’s sneakers.

In September 2022, film director Quentin Tarantino had to settle a Miramax lawsuit after base-layer blockchain provider Secret Network announced the auction of “uncut screenplay scenes” from Tarantino’s 1994 film Pulp Fiction as NFTs.

Tags
Artists
Nft
Art
Business
Law
Court
Related Posts
‘Wave of litigation’ to hit NFT space as copyright issues abound
Ownership is one of the most critical aspects of nonfungible tokens (NFT). They are a representation of the evolution of execution and ownership of art, content, music, in-game assets, etc., since they are digital assets with distinctive identities that are verifiable on a blockchain network. However, they have also created a new dimension of discussion about the interaction and grey area around copyright, intellectual property (IP) and trademark laws. In a recent highly publicized fiasco in the cryptoverse, crypto decentralized autonomous organization (DAO) Spice DAO was mocked for believing that the ownership of a copy of the unpublished manuscript of …
Music / Feb. 7, 2022
Chinese court rules marketplace guilty of minting NFTs from stolen artwork
A court in the Chinese city of Hangzhou issued a one-of-a-kind judgment against a nonfungible token (NFT) marketplace for allowing a user to create (or mint) NFTs of stolen artwork. As reported by South China Morning Post, the court verdict toward the NFT marketplace was made after Shenzhen-based company Qice filed a lawsuit against NFTCN’s parent company, BigVerse. The lawsuit claimed that an NFTCN user stole a copyrighted artwork of Ma Qianli, a Chinese artist specializing in drawing and printing. The user of the NFT platform allegedly poached one of Ma’s cartoons. Based on the evidence collected, the court found …
Artists / April 26, 2022
Russia’s Hermitage museum to host NFT art exhibition
Russia’s State Hermitage Museum, the second-largest art museum in the world, is preparing to host a digital art exhibition involving non-fungible tokens. Scheduled to take place in 2021, the Hermitage’s NFT project will be Russia’s first exhibition in the field of NFT art, the museum officially announced Thursday. The Hermitage’s contemporary art department is organizing the exhibition, which will be part of its “Hermitage 20/21” project. The announcement read: “Non-fungible tokens have become a new form of securing rights to an artwork using blockchain technology, which allows you to establish unambiguous control over copyright and ownership rights.” The Aksenov Family …
Artists / March 26, 2021
Adidas enters the Metaverse with NFT partnerships
On Thursday, Adidas announced it was entering the Metaverse in collaboration with Bored Ape Yacht Club, gmoney NFT, and PUNKS comic. In an article posted on the Adidas mobile app, the developers behind the initiative said the following: This autumn, Adidas, known for celebrating ideas at the bleeding edge of originality, it settling in at the frontier of creativity: The Metaverse. Our goal there? To see every one of its inhabitants thrive. The Metaverse is where anyone can express their most original ideas and be their most authentic selves, in whatever form they might take. And thanks to the blockchain …
Adoption / Dec. 2, 2021
NFTs are changing the way photographers create and market content
Since their explosion last year, nonfungible tokens (NFTs) have shown their appeal to collectors, investors and traders alike. They have especially gained attention in the art world, where an item’s provenance is everything, and owning the official, unique version of an item is much more valuable than a copy or duplicate. Some have postulated that artists creating and storing pieces on-chain can use the technology as proof of ownership for popular art forms. Among the various artforms to take advantage of NFTs, photography has also found its place, but what is the immediate value it brings for artists and consumers? …
Artists / March 27, 2022