What has been standing in the way of a pure-Bitcoin ETF?

Published at: Oct. 23, 2021

With regulatory bodies rumored to soon accept a pure Bitcoin (BTC)-backed exchange-traded fund, it is important to understand the journey of some of the first crypto-based ETFs that have recently been approved by government agencies.

The United States Securities and Exchange Commission approved a Bitcoin-adjacent ETF, giving investors the opportunity to gain exposure to Bitcoin through the stock markets, and the most recent acceptance was that of the ProShares Bitcoin Strategy ETF, which started trading on NYSE Arca on Oct. 19.

It's important to note that the aforementioned exchange-traded funds are not pure-crypto ETFs and merely track either crypto-related company stocks or futures contracts.

The SEC has yet to approve a pure-crypto ETF, unlike Canada back in the spring when regulators approved three Ether (ETH)-based ETFs from three different firms: Purpose Investments, Evolve ETFs and CI Global Asset Management.

Despite the good news of regulators beginning to accept crypto ETFs, many questions remain about why there have been so many challenges in listing them. This fall, there has been a lot of anticipation and speculation around what ETFs are exactly and how they can boost — or hinder — the crypto market as a whole. Here are the issues, challenges and possible future of crypto-backed exchange-traded funds.

Regulatory mismatch

Exchange-traded funds, in general, are investment funds that track a basket of assets on the stock market and can be traded in the same manner as regular stocks.

While there are ETFs for just about any asset, the problem with crypto is that there is still uncertainty among regulators about how to define Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies, and how to protect consumers against risk exposure. Those issues could present a challenge as pure-crypto ETFs begin to appear on stock markets, as not having regulatory clarity could cause problems with regulation across various national bodies and around the world.

The various financial regulatory agencies of the United States, for example, all have different — sometimes conflicting — views on what cryptocurrencies are, especially when it comes to taxation and trading.

In 2020, France’s principal financial regulator, the Autorite des Marches Financiers (AMF), responded to the European Commission’s guidance on so-called “crypto assets,” stating that it is still too early to explicitly define them. A spokesperson told Cointelegraph at the time:

“The AMF considers that giving a precise classification applied to crypto-assets could be premature at this stage. It is only after solid feedback that we will be able to judge the relevance of a precise classification (e.g. ‘utility tokens’, ‘security tokens’, ‘payment tokens’, ‘stablecoins’ etc.).”

French fund manager Melanion had its Bitcoin-adjacent ETF recently approved, with hopes to have its shares track the price of Bitcoin, first in the French market and soon in many other markets around Europe.

Cointelegraph reached out to Jad Comair, founder and chief information officer of Melanion, who mentioned that because it is not possible in the European market to directly expose investors to Bitcoin via the Undertakings for Collective Investment in Transferable Securities (UCITS) framework — which is “a format used by 99% of the ETFs listed in Europe” — the firm had to get smart and create “a world unique index construction methodology that measures companies’ Bitcoin exposure.”

This means that the ETF tracks the stocks of companies that invest in Bitcoin, mine Bitcoin or are otherwise involved in the crypto market, but it doesn’t contain Bitcoin itself. “The index selects the most exposed companies to Bitcoin, and weighs them according to their historical correlation (beta) to Bitcoin’s performance,” said Comair.

Fears vs. risks?

There still could be risks involved with highly volatile assets like cryptocurrencies, especially with a futures-backed Bitcoin ETF.

Bitcoin futures ETFs track a basket of futures contracts rather than Bitcoin itself. Since the futures price of Bitcoin may differ from the spot price, there is a possibility that the ETF may not accurately track the price of Bitcoin, exposing the ETF holder to some risk.

The term “contango” refers to when the futures price is higher than the spot price, while “backwardation” is when the futures price is lower than the spot price.

Related: Crypto breaks Wall Street’s ETF barrier: A watershed moment or stopgap?

Moreover, this high volatility means that regulators could move to implement more investor protection, especially after seeing the jumps that the crypto market has experienced in the past six months. This brings forth the question:

Could an exchange-traded fund help mitigate the risks that come with volatility?

With the fresh acceptance and implementation of crypto futures ETFs — the most recent model now trading on the New York Stock Exchange — this could “open the doors for the ‘real’ money to step in, as, for the time being, the existing Bitcoin products are eligible for small investment pockets, and Bitcoin itself is very complicated to put in a regular portfolio,” Comair stated. More serious exposure to the markets, even if via companies investing in Bitcoin, could push the market into explosion and/or stability.

It is possible that the changes in the crypto market could push for more ETF acceptance as the stock market learns how to interact with the crypto market — and vice versa. With ETFs tracking companies investing in crypto and the onset of futures-based crypto ETFs, could this lead to more widespread adoption of crypto investing as a whole?

Tags
Etf
Sec
Related Posts
Crypto breaks Wall Street’s ETF barrier: A watershed moment or stopgap?
A lot of excitement radiated out of New York this week with the launch of the first Bitcoin exchange-traded fund (ETF) sanctioned by the United States Securities and Exchange Commission. The ProShares Bitcoin Strategy ETF (BITO) had a stunning debut on the New York Stock Exchange as the second-most heavily traded opening-day fund on record, with some calling it “a watershed moment for the crypto industry.” But others, like Arca CEO Rayne Steinberg, had “mixed feelings” about the events. While pleased that a much-awaited crypto investment vehicle finally received regulatory approval — ending eight years of futility on the part …
Adoption / Oct. 22, 2021
Valkyrie Bitcoin futures ETF to launch on Nasdaq on Oct. 22
Valkyrie’s Bitcoin (BTC) futures-based exchange-traded fund (ETF) is poised to follow the launch of ProShares’ Bitcoin Strategy ETF on Friday. Valkyrie Bitcoin Strategy ETF is finally effective and is set to start trading on Nasdaq under the ticker BTF on Friday, Valkyrie confirmed to Cointelegraph on Thursday. The launch comes after the United States Securities and Exchange Commission granted a notice of effectiveness to Valkyrie Bitcoin Strategy ETF on Thursday. According to Leah Wald, CEO of Valkyrie Funds, the upcoming launch of Valkyrie’s Bitcoin futures ETF marks an important milestone in the relationship between the cryptocurrency industry and U.S. regulators. …
Adoption / Oct. 21, 2021
VanEck Bitcoin futures ETF to launch on CBOE on Nov. 16
VanEck, one of the first United States-based asset managers to file for a Bitcoin (BTC) exchange-traded fund (ETF), is finally launching its Bitcoin futures ETF. According to an official notice by the Chicago Board Options Exchange (CBOE), VanEck’s Bitcoin Strategy ETF will start trading on CBOE under the ticker symbol XBTF on Nov. 16. VanEck’s new ETF is joining the growing number of BTC futures-based ETFs launched in the United States, including ProShares’ Bitcoin Strategy ETF, which became the first Bitcoin futures ETF to start trading on the New York Stock Exchange on Oct. 19. Valkyrie’s Bitcoin Strategy ETF started …
Etf / Nov. 15, 2021
SEC rejects ARK 21Shares spot Bitcoin ETF application
The United States Securities and Exchange Commission, or SEC, has officially disapproved the application for ARK 21Shares Bitcoin exchange-traded fund. In a Thursday filing, the SEC rejected a proposed rule change from the Chicago Board Options Exchange, or Cboe, BZX Exchange to list and trade shares of the ARK 21Shares Bitcoin (BTC) ETF. The SEC said the proposed rule change, originally published for comment in the Federal Register in August 2021, would not be “‘designed to prevent fraudulent and manipulative acts and practices” nor “protect investors and the public interest.” The SEC said that the Cboe BZX Exchange had not …
Etf / April 1, 2022
Market manipulation claims will be hardest 'nut to crack' in Bitcoin ETF approval — WisdomTree
Will Peck, the head of digital assets at exchange-traded fund provider WisdomTree said regulators in the United States will “ultimately get there” on approving a Bitcoin spot investment vehicle, but dealing with claims of market manipulation could be a challenge. Speaking to Cointelegraph at the Converge22 conference in San Francisco on Sept. 29, Peck said WisdomTree would not follow Grayscale by taking legal action against the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission for denying its Bitcoin (BTC) ETF application. According to Peck, the company planned to “engage more productively” with the SEC without a lawsuit, but tackling some of the regulator’s …
Etf / Sept. 29, 2022